24 Oct 2014 14:41:45
Hello lads, ladies and Eds.

Its me again with my weekly question.

So the question is who you think was/is most over rated and under rated players? It can be someone famous or someone unfamous which should have been famous.

My answers would be pirlo as under rated player as in my eyes he should be labelled as wolrd class player in my eyes he is better than xavi or iniesta.

Over rated player has to be either rooney or balloteli both are terrible and plays for worst teams in the world.

By the way thanks for your replies and for keeping this site entertaining we have few discussions and site looks much better already keep it up!

{Ed001's Note - over rated Rooney or Beckham for me. I wouldn't include Balotelli as most people think he is crap. No wait, that probably is over rating him thinking about it.

Under rated would be Vinny Jones. Strange choice I know, but people don't realise he could play a bit as well as kick people. He even went a whole season without a booking once, when his manager asked him to concentrate on playing football. Most of the time he was just asked to put his foot in and he did that.}

1.) 24 Oct 2014
Most over rated for me would have to be Hulk.

Most under rated would be Paul McGrath.

{Ed018's Note - Hulk is definitely up there for me. And Rafael only because ed004 can't get off his knob}

2.) 24 Oct 2014
24 Oct 2014 19:07:29
ill make my answers pertain to the epl presently.
Overrated: Robin van Persie for me has to be up there. He had two fantastic seasons (2011-2013) but has had overall disappointing years beyond that. He also always seems to be carrying an injury. Mesut Ozil is an obvious selection but I feel people are beginning to see he was a product of his environment at Madrid. Jack wilshire is also up there for me. England as a whole is desperate to champion him after any above average performance. he's constantly injured, a poor professional, and basically a product of being so young when he got introduced to the big time.
Underrated:Fernandinho and Matic are both incredibly underrated. credit so commonly goes to the guys ahead of them but these guys allow the likes of toure and fabregas to play the way they do. Also Jordan Henderson, he was s_ _ _ when he got to Liverpool but the work he puts in is covering for Gerard's lack thereof.

3.) 24 Oct 2014
Over-rated - Glen Johnson - his positional play is still as bad as it was for us.
Over-rated - David Luiz (but only by PSG!).
Over-rated - definitely Rooney - world class my arse!
Under-rated - Aspilicueta, Dennis Wise, Gareth Barry (a bit leftfield but I think he should still be playing for England).
Becoming over-rated - Lallana.

4.) 25 Oct 2014
Overrated: Hulk, David Luiz and Rooney
Underrated: Azpilicueta, Pirlo and Kagawa

5.) 25 Oct 2014
Overrated Rooney and hulk and shaw

Underrated - Di Maria (on here lol), azpillicueta

6.) 25 Oct 2014
Overrated ; rio Ferdinand
Underrated; I would have to say ivanovic. For a centre half to play right back, nine times out of ten they would be awful. Ivanovic is really consistent and not just this season. Maybe moving back to centre half when terry calls it a day.

7.) 26 Oct 2014
26 Oct 2014 11:59:18
Over rated - Gerrard, headless chicken who runs around a lot with no tactical awareness. Talented player with no football brain who leaves his team mates exposed.